News & Insight
Board meetings and AI note takers: minutes, privilege, subject access and rules of preservation
Many board meetings now leave two records. One is the minutes. The other is whatever the AI note-taker wrote down.
The minutes are the company’s considered account of the meeting, usually approved by the board and signed by the chair. The transcript is every word, or what the software took to be every word, including the asides and second thoughts that nobody would have put in writing.
Minutes are required by law. The transcript usually is not, and it may exist only because someone switched a tool on. It sits beside the minutes, and a shareholder in a dispute, an employee, a regulator or a buyer in due diligence may each find a route to both.
The problem with the note-taker is less that it produces poor minutes than that it creates a separate evidential record without the board necessarily having considered the legal consequences of creating and keeping it.
Minutes and a transcript do different jobs
Section 248 of the Companies Act 2006 requires minutes of all proceedings at directors’ meetings, kept for at least ten years. Minutes record those proceedings and the decisions taken; they are not a verbatim record. Set minutes and transcript side by side and the gaps can look like concealment, when they show only the difference between a summary and a recording.
Signed minutes are evidence, not the last word
Under section 249, minutes authenticated by the chair are evidence of the proceedings. Until the contrary is proved, the meeting is deemed duly held and convened, its proceedings duly to have taken place and its appointments valid. Those presumptions go to regularity: the minutes are not conclusive evidence of what was said. If a dispute turns on what was said, considered or decided, a transcript may become competing evidence, although it is not more reliable merely because it is longer.
Making a transcript is processing personal data
Recording a meeting processes the personal data of everyone in it. The ICO has said, in a published answer to an organisation’s question, that an organisation using an AI tool for meeting recordings and notes can keep relying on its existing lawful bases. The answer assumes three things: the tool serves no new purpose or activity, it is not used to help make decisions about people and no personal data goes to the provider for the provider’s own purposes. The ICO adds that privacy notices should be updated to say how the tool is used, and that the organisation must check the tool’s output for accuracy. Sharing personal data with the provider, for example to train its model, needs its own lawful basis, and a provider that uses the content for its own purposes is likely to be a controller in its own right.
Before switching a tool on, the company should know why it needs a transcript and on what lawful basis, tell participants what will happen to it and find out whether the supplier can use it for training or human review. It should also check whether special category data, such as an executive’s health, needs an Article 9 condition, whether the risk calls for a data protection impact assessment (Article 35) and whether an overseas supplier needs transfer safeguards.
Disclosure and subject access reach the transcript
Under PD 57AD, which governs disclosure in the Business and Property Division of the High Court, ‘document’ expressly includes “voicemail, audio or visual recordings” (para 2.5), and a transcript held on a supplier’s system will often be within the company’s control. A transcript the company knows to be adverse to its case must be disclosed at the prescribed stage whether or not any order for disclosure is made, unless privileged (para 3.1(2)); a merely relevant one is disclosable within the scope of any order.
Personal data in a transcript may also be caught by a subject access request. The requester is entitled to a copy of their personal data, which may be an extract, rather than to the transcript itself, and only to what a “reasonable and proportionate search” produces (Article 15(1A) UK GDPR, inserted by the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025). A transcript can usually be searched by name, which can make it harder to argue that searching it would be disproportionate.
What directors say about an executive will often be that executive’s personal data. The copy must not adversely affect the rights and freedoms of others (Article 15(4)). Under Schedule 2 to the Data Protection Act 2018, information about other people may be withheld or redacted unless they consent or it is reasonable to disclose it without their consent.
Schedule 2 also protects privileged material. It allows management forecasts to be withheld where disclosure would be likely to prejudice the conduct of the business, and the company’s intentions in negotiations with the requester where disclosure would be likely to prejudice those negotiations.
A lawyer in the room does not make the meeting privileged
Legal advice privilege protects confidential communications between lawyer and client made for the dominant purpose of giving or getting legal advice. In R (Jet2.com Ltd) v Civil Aviation Authority [2020] EWCA Civ 35 the Court of Appeal held that a dominant purpose test applies and that a lawyer’s mere presence does not make a meeting privileged. Where the dominant purpose of a discussion is commercial, it will not generally be privileged, although passages of legal advice within it may be. Many board meetings have a predominantly commercial purpose, so a transcript may well mix privileged passages with unprivileged discussion.
Within a company, the ‘client’ for legal advice privilege is narrowly defined (Three Rivers District Council v Bank of England (No 5) [2003] EWCA Civ 474). Automatic circulation of a transcript may send legal advice to observers, investor representatives and advisors whose place in that client group is uncertain, or to recipients who have not received it on a limited and confidential basis. Disclosure in confidence for a limited purpose need not amount to a general waiver of privilege (Berezovsky v Hine [2011] EWCA Civ 1089), but the company would have to establish the scope of the permitted use.
The transcript may also sit on the supplier’s servers or within a cloud environment it controls. Confidential processing on the company’s instructions need not itself destroy privilege. But if the supplier may train its own model on the content, use it for its own purposes or allow unrelated human review, it becomes harder to show that the disclosure was confined to a limited and confidential processing arrangement.
Retention needs a policy and a legal-hold override
The Companies Act does not require a board-meeting transcript to be retained merely because one was created: section 248 applies to the minutes. A short retention period, such as deletion once the minutes are approved, fits the principle that personal data should not be kept longer than necessary, but it must yield to any legal hold, regulatory investigation, subject access request or other retention obligation.
Under PD 57AD, a company that knows it is or may become a party to proceedings must take reasonable steps to preserve documents in its control that may be relevant (para 3.1(1)). That includes suspending relevant deletion routines (para 4.2(1)). It also includes taking reasonable steps so that third parties holding documents on the company’s behalf, which may include its note-taking supplier, do not delete them (para 4.2(3)). Elsewhere in multi-track proceedings, PD 31B requires lawyers to tell clients to preserve disclosable documents as soon as litigation is contemplated.
Once a subject access request has been made, deliberately deleting a transcript to stop the requester receiving information they are entitled to can be a criminal offence (section 173 of the Data Protection Act 2018). Deletion that would have happened anyway is a defence.
The other side’s note-taker
In a deal, investor or without prejudice meeting, the counterparty’s note-taking tool records into the counterparty’s account under its own supplier contract. Unless the NDA or process letter deals with it, the company will have no direct control over its settings, how long the transcript is kept or who receives it. That does not leave the counterparty unconstrained: confidentiality, data protection and other applicable duties may still restrict its use. Supplier terms differ on training, human review and retention, and the company will not have seen the counterparty’s.
If the meeting is genuinely conducted on a without prejudice basis, recording it does not by itself remove the protection, which governs the admissibility of evidence rather than whether a record exists (Oceanbulk Shipping & Trading SA v TMT Asia Ltd [2010] UKSC 44, para 23). But the transcript still exists. It gives the recognised exceptions, such as whether a settlement was concluded, more material to work with, and it risks being copied or shared beyond the intended audience. Often the right answer is no note-taker at all.
Off by default, on for a reason
Transcripts have real benefits: they help directors working in a second language or who find a fast discussion hard to follow, and they make a complex discussion easier to check. Those benefits can justify recording a particular meeting or item for a defined purpose, not an always-on default.
Our recommendation is that boards decide meeting by meeting whether to record, with recording off by default. The ICO’s guidance on monitoring workers, which refers expressly to recording devices in meeting rooms and to video conferencing apps, advises organisations to switch off by default any capability to record audio. That guidance is written for employers monitoring workers, not for boards, so it supports the recommendation by analogy only. In practice, responsibility should sit with named people:
- The chair decides before each meeting whether transcription is justified and tells everyone attending at the outset. Agenda items involving legal advice, deal negotiations or without prejudice discussions should be presumptively unrecorded.
- The general counsel, company secretary or whoever keeps the minutes sets the policy on permitted uses, circulation and retention, with a legal-hold override, and checks the draft minutes against any transcript before the board approves them.
- Whoever buys the tool chooses terms and settings that exclude supplier training and unnecessary human access, allow deletion to be suspended and show where the data is held.
- The deal team agrees with the counterparty, in writing before the meeting or failing that expressly at the outset, whether recording is permitted and, if so, who controls and receives the transcript, whether supplier training is excluded and when it will be deleted.
This Insight was written by Robert Humphreys and Henry Humphreys. If you have any questions, please contact either of them or another member of the HLaw team.
All the thoughts and commentary that HLaw publishes on this website, including those set out above, are subject to the terms and conditions of use of this website. None of the above constitutes legal advice and is not to be relied upon. Much of the above will no doubt fall out of date and conflict with future law and practice one day. None of the above should be relied upon. Always seek your own independent professional advice.
Humphreys Law
If you would like to contact a member of our team, please get in touch by filling in the form below.
"*" indicates required fields
Humphreys Law